USASandwichLunch

The Moist Maker (Leftover Turkey Sandwich)

The gravy-soaked extra slice of bread from Friends, built for real: layered turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce and gravy between three slices instead of two.

prep
10 min
cook
5 min
total
15 min
serves
2
level
easy
Thanksgiving Moist Maker Sandwich.

Ross Geller was right about one thing: the extra slice of bread soaked in gravy and tucked in the middle of a leftover turkey sandwich is the single best use of Thanksgiving leftovers there is. Roommates throwing it out is a tragedy. This is the real version, built to actually hold together.

method

  1. Lightly toast all 6 slices of bread so they hold up to the gravy without going soggy too fast.

  2. Pour the warm gravy into a shallow dish. Dip one slice of bread into the gravy on both sides until it's soaked through but not falling apart: this is the "moist maker," the middle slice.

  3. Spread mayonnaise on one outer slice and cranberry sauce on the other outer slice.

  4. Build the sandwich: bottom slice (mayo side up), half the turkey, a layer of warm stuffing, salt and pepper, then the gravy-soaked moist maker slice in the middle.

  5. Add the remaining turkey on top of the moist maker, a spoonful more cranberry sauce, then the top slice (cranberry side down).

  6. Press down gently, slice in half, and eat immediately while the gravy slice is still warm.

chef's tips

  • Toast the outer bread but keep the middle slice untoasted: it needs to soak up gravy, not repel it.
  • Use turkey and stuffing straight from the fridge reheated, not cold: a cold sandwich with a warm gravy slice in the middle is an unpleasant mix of temperatures.
  • This only works with real pan gravy that's thick enough to cling to bread: thin gravy just makes it soggy. Reduce it on the stove for a few minutes first if it's thin.