Gefilte Fish
Poached whitefish dumplings served cold with jellied stock and horseradish.
- prep
- 40 min
- cook
- 1 h 30 min
- total
- 2 h 10 min
- serves
- 8
- level
- hard

method
Make the stock first: simmer the fish bones, heads, and skin with the quartered onion, sliced carrot, and celery in water to cover for 30-40 minutes.
Strain and reserve the stock, seasoning it with salt, sugar, and pepper to taste.
Mix the ground fish with the grated onion, grated carrot, eggs, matzo meal, sugar, salt, white pepper, and ice water until well combined and slightly sticky.
With wet hands, form the mixture into oval patties or quenelles.
Gently lower the patties into the simmering strained stock, adding the reserved sliced carrot rounds for garnish.
Simmer uncovered for 45-60 minutes.
Carefully lift the fish out and let cool, then strain the stock.
Chill the fish and stock separately: the stock will set into an aspic.
Serve the fish cold or at room temperature topped with a slice of carrot and a spoonful of the jellied stock, with horseradish on the side.
chef's tips
- Don't skip making stock from the bones: it's what gives gefilte fish its traditional texture and the jelly served alongside it.
- Serve with plenty of prepared horseradish (chrain), the classic pairing.